Nathalie BULLE, The Squirrel, the Symbol, and the Social: On Stephen Turner’s Naturalistic Reconstruction of Social Theory, Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 2026

Abstract
In Cognitive Science and the Reconceptualization of Social Theory, Stephen P. Turner naturalizes the social sciences, replacing concepts like culture and norms with a deflationary neurobiological approach. This review acknowledges the rigor of his critique against disembodied entities but argues his sociological eliminativism encounters a severe epistemological limit. By reducing human thought to sub-discursive pattern recognition, Turner dismisses the essential explanatory role of symbolically mediated meaning. Dispensing with the semantic nature of understanding renders the genesis of culture, language, and social action incomprehensible. By sacrificing subjectivity, this attempt to ground social theory in neurobiology fails to account for social life.

Centre_national_de_la_recherche_scientifiquelogo-Sorbonne-Universite_image_650